How to trade or invest in oil in this market

A couple of months ago, WTI crude oil was selling for more than $100 a barrel. If you would have told a trader or an investor that WTI crude oil would be fighting to reach $50 today, he would probably have laughed at you. But today, traders and investors were cheering oil which saw WTI rise 3.6% to $49.21 a barrel. Is this the sign of a new trend, or is it simply short term noise fuelled by news like what's happening in Yemen? And more specifically, how to turn out a profit trading or investing in oil companies in that environment?

How to invest in oil?

According to traders and investors I see arguing over oil prices on social medias, oil will go down, up, or sideways. Who's right? My answer will both disappoint and relieve you; they are all right. The reality is that asking where oil is going is asking the wrong question. Over long periods of time, we know that oil will fluctuate a lot from undervaluation to overvaluation, that's a fact of the "free" markets. Will oil go up in the long run? Of course it will! But do you have the patience to wait the time that it takes? If you're in for the long run, then buying oil now could turn out to be a lucrative idea. You could also buy puts options as insurance if you're scared oil might go dramatically down. They will protect the value of your shares, as your house insurance protects the value of your home. 

How to trade oil?

If you're a trader, then you don't have months or years in front of you to get your money back. You want your money in, and you want your miney out, with a profit. Why gamble by choosing a direction when you can bet on volatility? Oil volatility is near its peak as you can see on the chart below.

One strategy would be to buy a call option and a put option at the same strike price and same expiration. You would lose your premiums if oil move sideways, but you will make money if oil moves either up or down. However, if your expiration date is far enough, it is highly improbable that volatility will suddently remain flat until your options expire. 

Ask yourself the right question

Instead of trying to guess where oil is going, try to understand your position and what you want to do exactly. Then, adopt the right strategy for your position. Trying to guess day after day if oil will go up or down is a receipe for a lot of stress, frustration, and potentially portfolio disaster.